Best Auto Insurance Companies in Payette, Idaho

Compare Auto Insurance contractors in Payette, Idaho with websites, phone numbers, addresses, and company profiles. Updated August 2026.

4 Auto Insurance companies in Payette · showing 8 nearby within 100 miles.

In Payette

219 South Main Street, Payette, ID 83661
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Maya Mex Insurance & Services offers bilingual, female‑owned coverage across Idaho and Oregon, covering auto, home, renter, life, business liability, and travel to Mexico. With 14 years of experience, the agency emphasizes personalized, respectful service and flexible plans. Client reviews highlight Corina’s guidance and savings, and the gallery showcases local projects and community events.

208-642-6052 ma••••••@live.com mayamexone.com
815 Center Ave, Payette, ID 83661
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

FIG Insurance provides personalized insurance solutions, covering home, auto, life, health, and business policies. Clients benefit from in‑person service, rapid response, and expert plan selection. The firm emphasizes local presence, family values, and a commitment to resolving issues promptly. Customer testimonials highlight cost savings, reliable support, and competitive rates for clients today.

(208) 642-9565 pa••••••@fignow.com myfigfamily.com
921 Center Ave, Payette, ID 83661
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

All Valley Agency provides health insurance, Medicare, annuities, and group plans across Western states, covering major carriers. With over 90 years combined experience, the firm emphasizes personalized solutions, 24/7 support, and a family‑owned legacy since 1983. Client testimonials highlight clear communication, claim assistance, and a caring approach for individuals and businesses today.

208-291-1847 in••••••@allvalleyagency.com allvalleyagency.com
26 S Main Street, Payette, ID 83661
Auto Insurance Verified phone

Three Rivers Insurance offers a range of personal and commercial policies, including auto, home, renters, commercial auto, general liability, and recreational vehicle coverage. Clients can obtain quotes online, request policy documents, and file claims through the site. The agency emphasizes local service, experienced agents, and a 112‑year community presence.

Near Payette

Closest available companies in nearby cities.

1611 N Whitley Drive Suite 2, Fruitland, ID 83619-2180
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Lisa Brown’s State Farm office offers auto, home, condo, renters, life, health, pet, and business insurance, plus banking and annuities. The team includes Spanish‑speaking representatives and provides online quotes, claim filing, and payment options. The agent’s 20‑year anniversary and dual Idaho‑Oregon licensing underscore local expertise and reliable service.

855-733-7333 al••••••@keen.io brownsinsurance.org
1710 N Whitley Dr, Suite A, Fruitland, ID 83619
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

FIG Insurance offers a range of coverage options—including auto, homeowners, life, umbrella, and commercial policies—across 27 states. Their independent agents compare rates from over 136 carriers, aiming to secure the best price for clients. The agency emphasizes local presence, carrier quality, and claims support, with a 5‑star rating from two Google reviews.

(208) 739-9028 je••••••@fignow.com figinsurance.com
301 E Grove Ave., Parma, ID 83660
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Trent Accounting offers comprehensive tax and accounting services, including business and individual tax preparation, tax planning, QuickBooks support, CFO services, and bookkeeping. The firm emphasizes personalized attention, industry expertise, and a focus on maximizing deductions. Client reviews highlight professionalism, clear communication, and reliable service for small businesses and families seeking financial guidance.

+120-872-25210 of••••••@trent-cpa.com canyoncountycpa.com
525 S. Middleton Rd. STE #100, Middleton, ID 83644
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

CSC Agency, a Farm Bureau Insurance provider, offers Idaho residents comprehensive coverage for homes, vehicles, recreational vehicles, boats, businesses, and life and health insurance. The agency emphasizes personalized service, local expertise, and a commitment to protecting clients’ most valuable assets. Online portals streamline claims filing and bill payments for customers today.

208-877-4729 cs••••••@idfbins.com cscagencyllc.com
10610 Highway 44 Suite A102, Middleton, ID 83644-5425
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Estefan Cespedes State Farm offers auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, health, and pet insurance, plus banking services. The office holds a 4.9‑star Google rating from 77 reviews, provides online quotes, claim filing, and payment options, and features Simple Insights articles on home and auto safety. The team includes licensed agents and a friendly, pet‑friendly environment.

855-733-7333 al••••••@keen.io sfmiddleton.com
130 E. Idaho Avenue, Homedale, ID 83628
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Provision Insurance offers Idaho and Oregon residents independent coverage options across property, casualty, life, health, and commercial lines. The agency compares rates from over 30 carriers, including Liberty Mutual, Progressive, Chubb, Travelers, and GEICO, to secure competitive pricing. Clients can access home, auto, motorcycle, and business policies tailored to local needs and budget.

(208) 337-7140 of••••••@provisioninsure.com provisioninsure.com
600 HWY 95 Suite C, Homedale, ID 83628
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Farm and Ranch Insurance provides tailored coverage for rural properties, including farm, ranch, equine, and personal insurance. The site offers free quotes, a farm‑network email list, and links to major carriers such as Chubb, American Reliable, and Travelers. Users can submit inquiries online and access resources for farmers and ranchers today.

208-572-5080 em••••••@sisinsurancegroup.com sisinsurancegroup.com
1115 Albany St, Caldwell, ID 83605
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Canyon County’s website offers a comprehensive portal for residents, featuring elected officials, open‑government tools, and a wide range of services such as motor‑vehicle title registration, building permits, driver’s‑license processing, and public‑records requests. Users can access court schedules, tax payment portals, and real‑time arrest and jail‑roster data, plus career listings and community resources.

208-454-7300 ri••••••@canyoncounty.id.gov canyoncounty.id.gov