Best Auto Insurance Companies in Caldwell, Idaho

Compare Auto Insurance contractors in Caldwell, Idaho with websites, phone numbers, addresses, and company profiles. Updated August 2026.

12 Auto Insurance companies in Caldwell.

4520 Cleveland Blvd, Caldwell, ID 83605
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Inas Auto Body Shop offers collision repair, glass and paint services, dent and rust removal, frame straightening, and custom paint. With over 25 years of experience, the shop handles all makes and models, provides free estimates, and works with insurance. Customer reviews highlight professional communication and meticulous workmanship for reliable vehicle restoration.

+1 208 286-6780 in••••••@gmail.com inasautobodyshop.com
6218 Cleveland Blvd, Caldwell, ID 83607
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Team Mazda offers a broad selection of new and certified pre‑owned Mazda vehicles, including the 2026 CX‑5, CX‑30, CX‑50, CX‑70, CX‑90, Mazda3, MX‑5 Miata, and hybrid models. The site features online pre‑qualification, a digital showroom, service scheduling, parts ordering, and current specials such as 0% APR financing and trade‑in offers for customers today.

208-455-0322 v.••••••@goteammazda.com goteammazda.com
721 Hannibal St, Caldwell, ID 83605
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Birds of Prey Motorsports offers a broad selection of new and pre‑owned powersports vehicles, including ATVs, UTVs, motorcycles, Sea‑Doos, Ski‑Doos, and Can‑Am models. The dealership features a digital CFMOTO zone, financing options, trade‑in valuation, service appointments, parts ordering, and current promotions such as 0% APR and rebates up to $1,500.

208.453.2126 su••••••@dealerspike.com birdsofpreymotorsports.com
2024 Blaine St, Caldwell, ID 83605-4343
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Garrett Miyauchi State Farm offers auto, homeowners, condo, renters, life, health, business, and pet insurance across Idaho and Oregon. With 35+ years of experience, the agent holds a ChFC designation and a 4.9‑star Google rating from 399 reviews. The site features online quotes, claim filing, and a mobile app for convenient access.

208-455-0112 al••••••@keen.io garrettmiyauchi.com
6115 Cleveland Blvd Suite 101, Caldwell, ID 83607
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Montoya Insurance Group offers Idaho residents a range of policies, including auto, home, commercial, life, motorcycle, RV, and umbrella coverage. Clients can compare quotes online and access a client portal for policy management. The firm partners with carriers such as Travelers, Encompass, Foremost, Liberty, MetLife, Progressive, and Safeco.

888-527-9488 em••••••@gmail.com montoyainsurancegroup.com
209 Phoenix Ln Ste 106, Caldwell, ID 83605
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

The Windshield Doctor offers auto‑glass repair and replacement across Idaho, serving Boise, Nampa, Caldwell, Twin Falls, and surrounding counties. Established in 1978, the family‑owned firm provides same‑day service, free estimates, insurance claim handling, and a lifetime leak‑and‑stress‑break guarantee. Customers note quick, reliable, and affordable service for all vehicle types.

541-889-9292 ar••••••@yahoo.com thewindshielddoctor.net
211 Evans St, Caldwell, ID 83605
Auto Insurance Verified phone

Uria Auto Body provides comprehensive collision repair, including body work, paintless dent repair, frame and unibody restoration, and auto‑glass services. The shop holds I‑Car Gold and Ford Certified Collision Network credentials, ensuring high‑quality, OEM‑approved work. Financing and deductible assistance options are available, and the facility serves Nampa and Caldwell, Idaho region.

524 South 9th Avenue Ste 101, Caldwell, ID 83605
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Shaffer Buck Insurance offers independent, personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses, covering auto, home, life, and commercial policies. With over a century of experience, the firm emphasizes tailored coverage, competitive pricing, and reliable customer support. Clients can request a free, no‑obligation quote online or by phone today.

208.454.1401 in••••••@shafferbuckinsurance.com shafferbuckinsurance.com
1115 Albany St, Caldwell, ID 83605
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Canyon County’s website offers a comprehensive portal for residents, featuring elected officials, open‑government tools, and a wide range of services such as motor‑vehicle title registration, building permits, driver’s‑license processing, and public‑records requests. Users can access court schedules, tax payment portals, and real‑time arrest and jail‑roster data, plus career listings and community resources.

208-454-7300 ri••••••@canyoncounty.id.gov canyoncounty.id.gov
2922 Cleveland Blvd Suite 500, Caldwell, ID 83605-6962
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Eduardo Diaz State Farm offers auto, home, renters, life, and business insurance, plus banking and investment services. The agent holds a 5‑star Google rating from 56 reviews and serves the Caldwell, ID area. Spanish‑speaking support is available, and the office provides online quotes, claim filing, and 24‑hour phone assistance for customers today.

855-733-7333 al••••••@keen.io diazinsuranceidaho.com
4618 Beacon Ln Ste 108, Caldwell, ID 83605
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Steiger Agency offers personalized insurance solutions for homeowners, renters, auto, life, and recreational vehicle coverage, backed by carriers such as Farmers, Travelers, and Liberty Mutual. Clients benefit from a 4.9‑star Google rating, 98% satisfaction, free quotes, annual policy reviews, and claims advocacy, with a focus on transparent, responsive service.

(208) 459-0061 yo••••••@email.com steigeragency.com
2805 Blaine Street Suite 130, Caldwell, ID 83605-4686
Auto Insurance Verified email Verified phone

Mike Hanson’s State Farm Agency in Caldwell, ID, offers auto, homeowners, renters, life, and business insurance, plus banking and investment services. The agency holds a 4.8‑star Google rating from 215 reviews, serves over 3,000 households, and provides 24‑hour virtual meetings. It also offers a mobile app for policy management and online claims.

855-733-7333 al••••••@keen.io mikehansonsf.com